Movie Review: The Shape of Water


There are spoilers in this review. Duh.

It’s funny to be so behind on reviews that now this movie has won the Oscar for Best Movie and I can’t be all “I called this months ago” because I don’t have proof. And also because I didn’t call it. I never thought it would win, but of the nominated movies, it was my favorite. This whole thing is so fascinating because you would never have thought that a movie about falling in love with a fishman, with the leads all being minorities of some kind (black, gay, mute), would get the attention it did. Years ago it certainly would not have. Guillermo del Toro is a respected director, but always as that person people recognize as talented, but maybe not Oscar level talented. It was just the year for a horror-love story, I guess? It’s the first science fiction-esque (although maybe fantasy? It’s hard to say.) movie to win. And it deserved it.

The Shape of Water is about Elisa Esposito (played by the incredible Sally Hawkins), a woman who lost the power of speech to a childhood injury and works as a janitor at a secret government science lab. She is overlooked by everyone, but she leads a rather peaceful if mundane life. She is best friends with fellow janitor Zelda (Octavia Spencer) and her neighbor Giles (Richard Jenkins), a struggling gay illustrator. One day, they bring a top secret prisoner to the lab, what appears to be an animalistic fishman (Doug Jones) who is dangerous enough to bite fingers off and kill. Elisa however sees something gentle in him, and something vastly more intelligent than others realize. She teaches him sign language because she understands what it’s like to lack communication skills and for others to write her off because of it. This is while dodging the terrifying Colonel Strickland (Michael Shannon), who tortures the creature and creepily preys on Elisa. He visibly seems like the perfect man of the 1960s; handsome, powerful, egotistical, short sighted, and violent.

When Elisa finds out they plan on killing the fishman and dissecting him, she begs her friends to help her save them, and they find an unexpected partner in a secret Russian spy/doctor who was part of the experiment. He figures saving this creature – who has super powers of healing he wants to investigate – is better than letting it die. There is this scene where she explains to Giles why he has to help her, with him basically going ‘it’s a creature not a person,’ and her expressing in very articulate sign language and emotion that he is so very wrong in underestimating how important this creature is to her. Here’s the quote: “When he looks at me, the way he looks at me… He does not know, what I lack… Or – how – I am incomplete. He sees me, for what I – am, as I am. He’s happy – to see me. Every time. Every day. Now, I can either save him… or let him die.” It’s just … seriously. Sally Hawkins. She says so much without a single word, and when she does speak in a dream sequence, it’s so beautiful and sad. Anyway, we all know that it’s the movie about the woman who has sex with a fishman, and she does. They fall in love and have sex and he’s slowly wasting away in an environment not his own. So she has to find a way to save him, even if it means letting him go forever.

This movie is beautiful, in story and in visual design. Guillermo del Toro is an incredible visionary. The plot is simple and yet complicated at the same time, but it’s rather lovely. And it was basically the only happy movie nominated, because yes, spoilers, it has a happy ending. Or it’s implied to be a happy ending (that del Toro confirmed). She is healed by her love and they swim off together to live happily ever after. This is a strange film too, I really never would’ve pegged it as a sleeper hit or a best picture nom, but I can see why it is too. For one, maybe everyone wanted a whimsical weird fantastical romance period piece? Maybe there was something about it that touched the heart, with its excellent acting and underdog characters. Oh all credit needs to go to Doug Jones for his fantastic motion capture performance. When are they going to allow motion capture as a best acting option???? He and Andy Serkis are not given their dues. I definitely liked that this ragtag crew of lonely misfits managed to save the day. And we can’t ignore that it’s three repressed classes (race, sexual orientation, disability) that managed to save another (…honestly he could represent so many things, just general misunderstood victim?).

I came away from the movie smiling and impressed with how it pulled off what in description seems ridiculous. A mute woman in the Cold War falls in love with fishman. Are we supposed to root for them? YES YOU ARE. And if you aren’t sold on their love by the end of the movie, I don’t know. To each their own. But I for one am on board this OTP.

Please follow and like us:


  1. People post links to websites that have (for example) live streaming football and they nearly always have .blogspot. in the link. When I follow these there is just match details and adverts, no football (even when I know the game is being played). Do I need to install something or sign up to something?.

  2. CLINIQUE 倩碧線上購物官網。瀏覽Clinique倩碧官方網站,了解更多線上購物、護膚、彩粧、香氛及禮品詳情。通過過敏性測試,百分百不含香料。

  3. LM SKINCENTRE 癦痣 皮膚問題 大部分的痣都屬於良性的,而每顆痣都有自己的生長模式,有時會變但亦可以維持不變,例如在懷孕及青春期階段,痣的顏色可能會加深,但隨着年月過去,痣的顏色又可能會減退甚至消失。然而,痣亦可能是皮膚癌 (惡性黑色素瘤) 的徵狀,它們可以偽裝成一顆不斷改變的痣,因此最好由您的醫生為您進行全面的評估。

  4. I happen to be commenting to let you be aware of of the exceptional discovery my friend’s girl had going through your web page. She picked up many things, including how it is like to have an incredible helping style to make folks with ease comprehend some specialized subject matter. You actually surpassed our expectations. Thanks for giving such insightful, dependable, educational and in addition fun tips about the topic to Mary.

  5. I just want to say I am newbie to blogs and truly liked this web-site. Almost certainly I’m going to bookmark your blog . You actually have perfect articles and reviews. Many thanks for revealing your website.

  6. My spouse and i have been now ecstatic that Ervin managed to conclude his preliminary research with the ideas he obtained in your blog. It is now and again perplexing just to choose to be releasing tips and hints which often a number of people have been trying to sell. And now we fully grasp we have got you to appreciate because of that. These illustrations you’ve made, the simple web site menu, the relationships you can make it possible to promote – it’s all spectacular, and it’s helping our son and our family understand that subject matter is awesome, and that’s rather pressing. Thank you for all the pieces!

  7. 今夏大熱糖果pool slides拖鞋,啱哂最愛踢拖嘅Bella Hadid? Marie Claire (HK) Edition 炎熱夏天又來臨,去年夏天Bella Hadid穿上運動型Adidas Adilette膠拖及Rihanna的蝴蝶結fancy Fenty Puma成為一股「踢拖」熱潮。今季又喺時候矖一曬糖果色pool

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.